Raw LLM Responses
Inspect the exact model output for any coded comment.
Look up by comment ID
Random samples — click to inspect
G
Just watch this episode again and it is now maybe a month after the fires in Mau…
ytc_UgxlfcfO7…
G
The problem is that, people won't care until Ai hits us...but if it hits, it wil…
ytc_Ugx8yhh5-…
G
We've heard the promise for SO MANY YEARS that things would be easier with autom…
ytc_Ugzd9hHQO…
G
Question: does this guy ever go back and listen to his own interviews and what h…
ytc_UgydVrwu-…
G
If you want these trucks to work with you why not become a truck mechanic instea…
ytc_UgxEwhmeI…
G
It's not robot soldiers, it's just like missles and other dangerous weaponry mad…
ytr_UgyUsy0gH…
G
just for the next couple of generations, because there are already human actors …
rdc_k9hmhnn
G
A pretrip needs to be done, a DVR needs to be filled out, air lines need to be h…
ytc_UgxwoXYGw…
Comment
If we take the "What Is It Like to Be a Bat?" definition of consciousness, then the best we can do is ask ourselves, "What does it feel like to be ChatGPT?" What does it experience?
The language models receive some text as input, and give back text as output. Does it "hear" the text? Does it "see" the text in a black screen and then think about it in words? When "thinking" of the output, does it hear it again? How does time pass for this AI? Is it continuous even when it's not working, or is it only when it receives an input?
As far as I can tell, there is no computer program that can make a computer conscious, because all that a computer can do is work with bytes. At the end of the day, it's always just a processor shuffling bytes in memory. It doesn't matter how complex your software is, the hardware is still incapable of consciousness.
Even if you had a computer that perfectly mimics what a human would do (with cameras for eyes, and microphones instead of ears), we could still affirm that it isn't conscious, because the data that it's processing is still discrete. This is more or less what John Searle was saying in the paper that coined the Chinese Room argument, that you need more than behavior if you want to assert that something is conscious.
youtube
AI Moral Status
2023-08-24T23:5…
Coding Result
| Dimension | Value |
|---|---|
| Responsibility | none |
| Reasoning | unclear |
| Policy | unclear |
| Emotion | indifference |
| Coded at | 2026-04-26T23:09:12.988011 |
Raw LLM Response
[
{"id":"ytc_UgyZMUEYPkEMBOu1PLh4AaABAg","responsibility":"none","reasoning":"unclear","policy":"unclear","emotion":"indifference"},
{"id":"ytc_UgxsexWjYwaKvBWX0KF4AaABAg","responsibility":"none","reasoning":"mixed","policy":"unclear","emotion":"indifference"},
{"id":"ytc_Ugztb5F7S8mkBmMTctV4AaABAg","responsibility":"none","reasoning":"unclear","policy":"unclear","emotion":"approval"},
{"id":"ytc_Ugy1zofO29LOVjSZHXJ4AaABAg","responsibility":"none","reasoning":"unclear","policy":"unclear","emotion":"indifference"},
{"id":"ytc_Ugwia89r2Fd87LS9fLN4AaABAg","responsibility":"ai_itself","reasoning":"consequentialist","policy":"unclear","emotion":"fear"},
{"id":"ytc_Ugy9B68jrdzL4K8Q0T14AaABAg","responsibility":"none","reasoning":"unclear","policy":"unclear","emotion":"indifference"},
{"id":"ytc_UgwUVoPfJVEd972_w4N4AaABAg","responsibility":"ai_itself","reasoning":"consequentialist","policy":"unclear","emotion":"fear"},
{"id":"ytc_UgyiOaMGEhKnq7rQAeZ4AaABAg","responsibility":"none","reasoning":"unclear","policy":"unclear","emotion":"mixed"},
{"id":"ytc_UgwVWJQA1dQ6vm3UeuF4AaABAg","responsibility":"none","reasoning":"mixed","policy":"unclear","emotion":"indifference"},
{"id":"ytc_Ugxwta0vfDgqfdc3xbx4AaABAg","responsibility":"company","reasoning":"consequentialist","policy":"none","emotion":"indifference"}
]